Friday, June 1, 2007

In Season: Cashton Amish Country

Take to the highway won’t you lend me your name
Your way and my way seem to be one and the same
Mamma don’t understand it
She wants to know where I've been
I’d have to be some kind of natural born fool
To want to pass that way again
But I could feel it
On a country road
— James Taylor, “Country Road”

Last month, I began a spring/summer series of road trips around our region with a visit to Lanesboro, Minnesota. I hinted that this series would be based in part on local wines…and while future installments will be, this month’s journey centers around a community that will have nothing to do with alcohol. It was sort of unplanned, to tell you the truth, but I reserve the right to be spontaneous and adaptive in this space. Hopefully the oenophiles among us will forgive me, especially since some of the treats we picked up along the way make a fine accompaniment to a glass of wine. Join us on a trip to…

Amish Country
As I mentioned last month, Lanesboro also has an Amish community; however, we’re more familiar with Cashton, Wisconsin, where my wife, Lisa, grew up. There may not be a lot of things to do in the Cashton area, but if you’re into pure scenic beauty and wholesome, handmade local products, you will love this daytrip. Wildcat Mountain State Park, between Cashton and Ontario, offers camping, hiking and canoeing on the upper Kickapoo River, and the drive through the park on undulating Highway 33 is one of the most breathtaking scenic displays I’ve ever experienced, especially in the fall. But that’s for another day. This particular weekend we were in search of good things to eat.

Our first stop was for things we can grow ourselves. Windy Ridge Greenhouse is Amish-owned, and is one of the finest greenhouses in the area. It also lives up to its name. The wind was really howling up on the ridge along County Road U that day between Cashton and tiny St. Mary’s. We bought some really nice flowers and some vegetable and herb plants for the garden, and the prices were very good. After our order was totaled up on an ancient non-electric adding machine, a little girl in traditional “plain” dress helped us load everything into the car and we were on our way.

If you’re not local and need a guide, our next stop is definitely for you. Down a Country Road is a charming little place along Highway 33 two miles east of Cashton. It consists of several little shops on Chuck and Kathy Kuderer’s farm. The main shop is called The Amish Shop, and features a variety of handcrafted treasures from local farms. Other shops on the premises feature non-Amish products—country crafts and gifts, gourmet foods and gardening items—and an ice cream shop selling hand-dipped Wisconsin ice cream.

Kathy Kuderer has gotten to know the local Old Order Amish well and offers tours of the nearby farms, where you can purchase handcrafted goods directly from the makers. Tours are scheduled by appointment May through October. Their Web site is www.downacountryroad.com.

Not needing a tour, we took a shortcut back road from the shop to County Road D, which is populated by one Amish farm after another. Nearly every farm has a sign along the road advertising what it sells: woven rugs, bent hickory furniture, maple syrup…Hey, this is a food column! How can I visit Amish country without some homemade maple syrup?

We drove into a farm and walked into the shed, which is typically where an Amish farm does its business. We were greeted by the aroma of hand-tanned leather, which was being stitched by a handsome young chap with a pedal-powered sewing machine. This shed was primarily a harness shop, and was filled with saddles, harnesses, bits, reins and everything a horse-powered family needs for its vehicles of choice. An elderly gentleman sat behind a desk, and we asked if he had any syrup. “Oh, yes,” he replied, and opened a cooled case with two plastic gallon jugs. We said a gallon was a bit much for our needs, so he went to get us a half gallon with the caveat that “the gallon gives you more for your money; it’s $30, and a half gallon is $17.” Have you priced pure maple syrup in the supermarket lately? Seventeen bucks is a bargain, and then some.

Maple syrup is legendary for being a labor-intensive product. First, maple trees are “tapped” with a spigot-like device which allows the sap to drip into a bucket hung from the tap. The farmer then collects all the buckets and pours the sap into a large cooker over a fire. It takes around 40 gallons of sap to make just one gallon of syrup. “It took all of that this year, too,” the gentleman told us. “The sugar content was pretty low.” The syrup was of a rich, darker shade which I prefer (the commercial “fancy” grade is very light, but I like the flavor of the apparently more pedestrian product). This ambrosia would grace a stack of buttermilk pancakes the following morning, and I’ll even give you my recipe at the end of this column. But first…

A Little Slice of Heaven
Further along County D is the kind of business that attracts a lot of people to Wisconsin. Old Country Cheese was founded by the Old Order Amish in 1982 when they decided that having their own cheese factory was the best way to provide Amish dairy farmers with a continuing market for milk shipped in traditional cans, thus ensuring an economic future for themselves and their children. The plant accepted its first milk in the spring of 1983—about 32,000 pounds per day from 77 Amish milk producers. Today it brings in around 120,000 pounds of milk per day from about 230 producers.

Although the plant is owned by the Amish, it is not operated by them. A modern cheese factory requires equipment that cannot be run by Amish folks, lest they run afoul of their religious doctrine. So they hired a local non-Amish guy to be their cheesemaker…and let me tell you, the guy makes a fine product. I asked whether the milk used was organic, since many of our readers care about such things and because the area is a hotbed of organic dairy farming. The non-Amish fellow behind the counter confirmed my suspicion when he replied that although they are not officially certified organic, the Amish are about as close as you can get. One needs only to spend a few minutes around these people to know that anything they put on their fields is much more likely to come from the back end of a cow than from a Monsanto bag.

The cheeses they make on site include fresh cheese curds (the ones we bought were made just that day and had that distinctive squeak when we bit into them), flavored Monterey Jack-based cheeses, Havarti, Colby, and their specialty, Cheddar. Old Country Cheese offers Cheddars of varying ages, from mild to sharp and on up through the years. In the cooler were 2-year-old, 4-year-old, 8-year-old and the king of them all, 10-year-old. The prices went up about a dollar per pound per year, with the 10-year-old topping out at $13.89 per pound. They offered tasting samples of the 10-year-old. My stepson, Leo, thought it was “disgusting,” but Lisa and I were hooked.

I asked the guy behind the counter how long “sharp” cheddar at the supermarket was aged. He said it was 9 months to a year. If 2 years is extra sharp, this stuff is razor-sharp. This is not the kind of cheese you’d put on your kids’ grilled cheese sandwich; it is definitely an acquired taste for more mature (jaded?) palates. You’ll even notice tiny, flaky crystals within the cheese that at first you think is salt. It’s actually calcium lactate, and while mass producers like Kraft would find these crystals to be a sales-hindering nuisance (and cannot invest the time to age their cheeses that long anyway), they are considered a badge of honor among lovers of vintage Cheddar, adding to its savor and acquired only through long periods of careful aging. The cheese does not slice smoothly and evenly from the block, but rather flakes off in deliciously imperfect shards that make a fine accompaniment to a fruity red wine or mellow Port. It is, without question, my new favorite cheese.

The store offers cheeses other than their own, as well; we purchased a couple of local delicacies besides the fresh curds and aged Cheddar from opposite ends of the spectrum. One was the Juusto (pronounced oo-stoe) cheese from nearby Pasture Pride Cheese in Cashton, another of the few plants in the state which accepts milk in cans from Amish producers. This cheese of Finnish origin, also known as “bread cheese,” is sliced and then quickly baked at a high temperature so it develops a light brown “crust” and looks like a slice of French toast. It has a mild, buttery flavor; we bought a chunk that was spiked with jalapeño peppers, and it was delicious.

Another fine cheese we bought there was Mindoro Blue, an award-winning Danish-style blue cheese made by Swiss Valley Farms at their plant in Mindoro, Wisconsin, not far from our home in Holmen. More buttery-smooth than its crumbly brethren, yet still riddled with those pungent veins of character, this excellent cheese is also best enjoyed with simple crackers and a nice Port or a sweeter white—maybe a Riesling—to complement its flavor. No offense to our Iowa friends who no doubt are loyal to their Maytag Blue, but this is definitely my favorite blue. Old Country Cheese is found online at www.oldcountrycheese.com.

From razor-sharp Cheddar to sweet maple syrup, this was one of the more flavorful road trips we’ve taken in recent memory. And now that recipe I promised…Lock Aunt Jemima in the closet, because fine maple syrup demands only real pancakes from scratch:

Homemade Buttermilk Pancakes
Grandma Severson taught me how to make these when I was little, and the kids just love them. The nutmeg and vanilla are my additions, and are a bit too flamboyant if you’re in an Amish mood.

1-1/4 cups flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1 tablespoon sugar
Pinch of salt
Dash of nutmeg (optional)
2 cups buttermilk
1 egg
2 tablespoons melted bacon grease (use vegetable oil if you must)
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract (optional)

Stir all dry ingredients together. Add wet ingredients and stir until well-incorporated, but do not overmix or batter will be too flat. A few lumps add character.

Preheat griddle between medium and medium-high. Coat with cooking spray. Pour batter onto griddle roughly 1/4 cup at a time to make pancakes about 5 inches in diameter. Cook until bubbles form on surface, then flip with spatula and cook until bottom is brown. Repeat until batter is gone, keeping griddle coated with spray between batches.

Serve with butter and pure maple syrup, and throw the Bisquick away unless you’re making biscuits.

No comments: